Lab-Grown Diamonds vs Diamond Simulants: Why Moissanite and CZ Are Not the Same Thing

Put a thermal diamond tester on a lab-grown diamond and it reads diamond. Put it on a moissanite and it reads diamond too. Moissanite conducts heat so much like diamond that GIA reported in 1997, as it was about to reach the jewelry market, that thermal probes reacted to it “as if it were diamond”. A tester that beeps tells you less than most buyers think.
A lab-grown diamond is diamond. Moissanite (silicon carbide) and cubic zirconia (CZ, zirconium dioxide) are different materials made to look like diamond. They differ in hardness, in how they return light, in how they age and in how testers read them. Both simulants are legitimate stones at lower prices, as long as they are sold under their own names.
Side by side
- Material
- Carbon
- Category
- Diamond
- Mohs hardness
- 10
- Refractive index
- 2.42
- Fire
- Diamond’s
- Brilliance
- Diamond’s
- Facet edges seen through the crown
- Sharp, single
- Over the years
- Unchanged
- Thermal tester
- Reads diamond
- Graded on a diamond report
- Yes
- Relative price
- Highest of the three
- Material
- Silicon carbide
- Category
- Simulant
- Mohs hardness
- 9¼
- Refractive index
- 2.648 and 2.691 (doubly refractive)
- Fire
- More than twice diamond’s
- Brilliance
- Close to diamond’s
- Facet edges seen through the crown
- Can look doubled
- Over the years
- Hard enough for daily wear
- Thermal tester
- Reads diamond
- Graded on a diamond report
- No
- Relative price
- Lower
- Material
- Zirconium dioxide
- Category
- Simulant
- Mohs hardness
- 8.5
- Refractive index
- Lower than diamond
- Fire
- Slightly more than diamond’s
- Brilliance
- Less than diamond’s
- Facet edges seen through the crown
- Sharp, single
- Over the years
- Yellows over time; facet edges wear
- Thermal tester
- Reads not diamond
- Graded on a diamond report
- No
- Relative price
- Lowest
The moissanite figures come from GIA’s 1997 study; the CZ and brilliance comparisons from GIA’s guide to imitations.
Is moissanite a lab-grown diamond?
No. Most moissanite sold in jewelry is also made in a laboratory, which is why the two get confused, but it is silicon carbide, not carbon. It has a different hardness, a different refractive index and more than twice the fire, and no laboratory will issue a diamond grading report for it. “Lab-made” describes how a stone was produced; “diamond” describes what it is. A lab-grown diamond is both, and moissanite is only the first.
How they look
- Lab-grown diamond returns strong white light with balanced flashes of color.
- Moissanite shows more than twice diamond’s fire, which reads as rainbow flashes, especially in stones of 1 ct and up and in sunlight. Because it is doubly refractive, the back facets can look doubled and the interior slightly blurry when you look through the crown at an angle. Some moissanites show a slight yellow or gray tint at certain angles.
- Cubic zirconia looks bright when new, with a little more fire and less brilliance than diamond. GIA notes that colorless CZ yellows over time, and at 8.5 on the Mohs scale its facet edges wear and round off with daily use.
How to tell them apart
Swipe the table to see more →
| Method | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Thermal tester | Separates CZ from diamond; reads moissanite as diamond |
| Loupe, looking through the crown at an angle | Doubled facet edges point to moissanite |
| Screening device | Most consumer devices give only “pass” or “refer”; GIA notes some can wrongly pass a simulant |
| Grading report checked online | Confirms diamond and whether it is laboratory-grown or natural |
None of these, apart from a laboratory, can tell a lab-grown diamond from a mined one. See do lab-grown diamonds look different from natural?
Other simulants you may see
Swipe the table to see more →
| Simulant | Material | Notes from GIA |
|---|---|---|
| White sapphire | Corundum | Hardness 9; less brilliant than diamond |
| Glass | Glass | The oldest imitation; less brilliant than diamond |
| Synthetic rutile | Titanium dioxide | Introduced in the late 1940s; slight yellow tint; now rare |
| Strontium titanate | Strontium titanate | Popular in the 1950s; over four times diamond’s dispersion; now rare |
Naming them correctly
Under the FTC Jewelry Guides, the unqualified word “diamond” may not be used for anything that is not diamond. A simulant has to be sold under its own name, “moissanite”, “cubic zirconia”, “white sapphire”, or as a “simulated” or “imitation” stone. Calling a moissanite a “lab diamond” or “diamond-like lab stone” misleads, because a lab-grown diamond is a different product. Lab-grown diamonds in turn need a qualifier such as “laboratory-grown”. If a price looks too low for a diamond, ask what the material is and ask for the report.
Which to choose
Which fits you?
Simulant questions
Is moissanite a real diamond?
No. It is silicon carbide, a diamond simulant, even when it is made in a lab.
Will a diamond tester catch moissanite?
A thermal tester will not; it reads moissanite as diamond. Look for doubled facet edges, or ask for a laboratory report.
Does cubic zirconia last?
It is softer than diamond, its edges wear, and GIA notes colorless CZ yellows over time.
Is white sapphire a good diamond alternative?
It is hard, at 9, but less brilliant than diamond.
Buy diamond, documented as diamond
NUVU supplies lab-grown diamonds, not simulants. Ask for the report number of any stone you are considering and check it on the laboratory’s website; NUVU can arrange IGI, GIA or NGTC reports. Send your requirements or message us on WhatsApp / WeChat at +86 19118403930.
Sources

7+ years researching color tuning, inclusions and defect characterization of lab-grown diamonds.

About NUVU. NUVU is the international brand of New Perspective Superhard Materials Co., Ltd. in Zhecheng, Henan, China. We grow HPHT lab-grown diamonds in-house and cut, polish and match stones in our own workshop.
Related Guides
Are lab-grown diamonds real diamonds?
Are lab-grown diamonds real?
Read more →Lab-grown vs naturalWhat are lab-grown diamonds?
What lab-grown diamonds are, how HPHT and CVD grow them, how they differ from natural diamonds and moissanite, how…
Read more →EducationLab-grown diamond education
Every NUVU lab-grown diamond guide in one place: 4Cs, certificates, HPHT vs CVD, prices, shapes, engagement rings…
Read more →
Loose lab-grown diamonds10 shapes · IGI, GIA or NGTC reports